Thanks to Charles McCarty for the identification. I recently rephotographed the store (2017).
The abandoned interior still retains some of the furnishings so common to country stores.
Debbie Pye O’Donnell writes: In the summer I stayed with with Mama Pye. She lived within walking distance and she often took me there for a cold soft drink. I remember the fresh wheel cheese and the penny candy Uncle Clifford always gave me.